I'm new to hammock camping and planning a two week trip to Iceland in October with a BlackBird XLC and set of struts. I'm trying to decide between a Warbonnet SuperFly and MacCat Four Season tarp. I've also looked at a few cuben fiber tarps, and while I can stomach their prices, I can't stand how they look and I don't think I'd benefit much from the reduced weight.

Recommendations between the two with specific reasons why one might be better would be greatly appreciated.