Currently I have a HG CF tarp. I really like it but I am not able to hike the distances that I used to. With my new distance limits I do not need to worry about the weight savings by using CF as much anymore.

I used to have a Superfly and liked it but felt is was a little too big at times. I am contemplating getting rid of the CF tarp and going back to a Warbonet tarp. In addition to the Superfly they also have the Mountainfly and Thunderfly. Since the SF was a little big for me before would I be in the same boat with the MF feeling that it might be a little big for me? I usually do not close my doors unless it is raining bad.

I would be interested in hearing from people who have switched from a SF to a MF or TF. What did you like about changing and what did you not like? Did they perform better than your SF?