No doubt you are. There are simply too many(for an easy decision at least) great quilts. But the positive side of that is: it is hard to go wrong with any of the well known brands often discussed here, and even a few brands that are rarely discussed. As for me, it is very hard to pick out a favorite among the different brands and types that I have used over the years. Quite a few have done me right.
1: I will start with the
newest which I have not yet been able to put to a good test, but which shows high promise, and which a few others have spoken highly of: SMR Inferno TQ/UQ (TQ 17.8 oz, UQ 20 oz for 30F, some have used them well below 30F no problem). These seem to have a lot of potential for approaching the draft proof fit and ease of set up that my old Speer Pea Pod had. Not quite, but probably closer than anything else.
The UQ has 2 unique thingies that may prove helpful:
A: END CAPs. This UQ tapers down on the ends to a point and a single connection cord, pretty much in the same shape as the hammock. As it tapers down to this point, there is a big puffy area(End Cap) on each end merging into a triangle that feels like it has a tiny bit down in it, but I'm not sure of that. Regardless, this seems to seal up around the bottom end of the hammock in a fashion that seems hopeful for avoiding drafts, pretty automatically if I adjust the tension so that the UQ is contacting my back. I don't know if this is actually any better at avoiding drafts from the ends(like my Pea Pod for sure was) but it seems to be, or at least easier to adjust for that benefit. Hard to explain, so here is a pic 1st on a Speer hammock and then on a Claytor. My head snuggles right down into that blue head end cap. Speer head end:
Claytor foot end:
Claytor:
B: There are adjustable elastics in the top side edges of the quilt that do a great job of snugging the UQ up against my sides. This also seems to have draft preventive possibilities, time will tell. Here is the UQ on a Claytor with some pack weight in the hammock, with a close view of the side fit, also you can see the green pillow in the head end cap:
Time will tell if this is actually any easier to avoid drafts between hammock and UQ compared to my more rectangular shaped UQs, and especially if it can approach the Speer Pea Pods draft resistance. That latter is a large challenge.
The SMR Inferno TQ has a built in hood and shoulder coverage that is just superb. It is essentially the equivalent of a mummy bag, but with the comfort of a quilt. (again, like a Pea Pod). During my beginning years as a hammock hanger, I had a real hard time staying warm using a sleeping bag as a TQ, due to draft issues around the neck especially if I moved in my sleep, and the loss of a thick sleeping bag hood. But that is not ever going to happen with this baby. I had many a cold night rescued by giving up and zipping into my mummy bag, which would often take me from too cold to sleep to toasty warm. Now admittedly, over the years I got a lot better at keeping a quilt draft free around my neck and shoulders, and a separate JRB hood greatly improved my success, and a dedicated quilt was easier to keep draft free around the neck than a mummy bag. So I'm not certain this will actually work any better than my JRB TQ + hood. But, it is possible to develop a draft around the neck with my other TQs, and it is really not possible with this rig. I am posting 2 pics, one from the front with the hood cinched closed a good bit(but will go further). It will open up wide or it is easy to even pull it down for no hood at all, but still has a great neck seal(NO draft possible) In the picture from the back, standing,
my feet are not in the foot box, so it is pulled somewhat forward, and the back is capable of closing a good bit more than what you see. But, I think you can still see how there is
not going to be any draft in the neck or shoulder area no matter how much you toss and turn. As far as I have been able to tell(and as others have confirmed) when I go to my side, I just twist it a bit from the neck down, not having much under me, and adequate back coverage is maintained.
So, this
may become my new favorite for non bridge hammocks(TQ for all types of hammocks). But is it really a lot better, or any better, than the great stuff I have always used? For a draft proof neck and shoulder fit, I think at least a bit better than the best, and a lot better than some. The UQ seems very promising also, but I must test near or under the rating. It will be hard to actually beat my older gear!
1:
Speer Pea Pod, especially used with narrow Claytor hammock: Under 40 oz for both TQ and full length 20F rated UQ, by far the most draft fee approach I ever used. I was never cold at or a bit below the rated 20F temp on the bottom, never a problem. Top a bit trickier due to tendency for hammock sides to raise the TQ section up off of you, creating a gap and less warmth. But when filled by clothing or the lightest possible TQ, as warm or even much warmer than rated. Above all else, draft proof. I never had a negative surprise using this. I don't know if TTTG is still making them.
2:
JRB UQs ( MW3 or MW4) used on my JRB bridge hammocks: flawless warmth, top of head to heels. No gaps whn used on bridge hammocks Used below rated temps without a problem, appeared to be very draft resistant. Not much, really nothing, to adjust. Just clip into the loops or rings, perfect fit each and every time. JRB(or any brand)
TQs also seemed to just work better, less draft prone, in these bridge hammocks, especially the deep original JRB bridge. Can't prove it, but seemed to. I also used these UQs on gathered hammocks with pretty good success, but took a bit more adjusting.
3:
WB Yeti- but original CS synthetic version. (no experience with down version, I'm sure it is great) My son used it successfully- with enough added CS for a total quilt weight probably about 18 oz, on his first ever hammock hang, on nights in the 20s and was plenty warm, and has never had an issue using since. I sometimes think these torso length UQs(with foot pads) are easier to use with less to go wrong or be adjusted wrong. Anyway, it has never let either him or me down.
4:
Hennessy Hammock Super Shelter(HHSS): I set my all time record in a slightly boosted version of this: 6F, toasty warm head to toe and could have def gone a good bit lower.( I consider basic system good into the 30s) It's huge advantage, if you have a Hennessy or some other hammock it will fit: wind and water proof is part of the system. That built in wind proofing is a big plus.
5:
AHE Apex Jarbidge and Ridge Creek(for WB bridge only): I have never really put my Jarbidge to the test, but I have read many a testimonial to the JB here, and I have high confidence in it, and it is a bargain(is it still on sale?)
I don't see how you can go wrong with any of those that you can find, and no doubt a few others that I have not tried. Just pick one and you will be good to go. There is really not that much difference, just some pros and cons for each one.
Bookmarks