Fastmatt - when you went to middle settlement lake, did you go on the lost lake trail? It heads west from middle Settlement lake, forks and then heads north. I read that that was overgrown and had a number of swampy / boggy areas.
I also read that the Big Otter lake trail had a section that required 'wading' - between the Middle Branch lake trail and the East Pond trail.
Essentially we were trying to do the loop around Middle Branch lake and that passes by Middle settlement lake.
I'm getting my information from the 2003 edition ADK Guide to adirondack trails - so it's quite old. It seems hard to find a good source of information about trail conditions / etc.
Thanks
Bookmarks